top of page

Scotland wants more control over broadcasting, but who really wins?

Writer: Billy
Billy
1 day ago
3 min read

Last week, the Scottish Government voted in favour of a new bill that would see broadcasting in Scotland become a devolved matter, meaning the Scottish Government would take control rather than the UK Government.


It is widely seen as a response to last month's announcement of the closure of the BBC Scotland channel alongside two other national services.


Devolution in a nutshell

According to the Government's own definition, devolution is the breaking up and transfer of power from the central government to local authorities. For example, power of Greater Manchester's budget was previously the responsibility of the central government, but the GMCA (Greater Manchester Combined Authority) was set up in 2017 and now takes full control of spending in the region.


Scotland has had a devolved government since 1999 and has the strongest devolution powers of anywhere in the UK. Scotland has its own laws, legal system, and courts, as well as an education system that is completely different to that of the rest of the UK. Responsibility for railways is also a devolved matter.


Now, Holyrood wants to add broadcasting to that list in the wake of BBC cuts and channel closures.


Màiri McAllan, Secretary for Education, Culture and Gaelic, described the closure of the BBC Scotland channel as "the latest in long line of blows to the Scottish media landscape" and voiced her support for the devolution motion.


Others, though, aren't so convinced. Writing for The Scotsman, columnist Brian Wilson acknowledged that although the channel's viewing figures were low and a sign of "the pace of change in how television is consumed", he expressed concern that devolution of broadcasting will only seek to serve "power hungry SNP ministers", rather than the viewers of Scotland.


The Scottish Government had drawn up plans for public broadcasting as early as 2024 in a white paper titled "Building a New Scotland: Culture in an Independent Scotland ". It proposed the creation of an entirely new broadcaster for Scotland which would have better authority over news and sports events, as well as showcasing Scottish culture to a global platform. Indeed, the white paper even mentions participation in Eurovision under its new broadcaster.


BBC vs indyref2

The devolution case could also be a subtly unsubtle snipe at the BBC for its perceived views on a second Scottish independence referendum. For those unfamiliar with recent Scottish history, a referendum was held in 2014 asking whether Scotland should remain as part of the UK or become a sovereign state in its own right. The ruling Scottish National Party (which still runs Scotland today) backed the 'Yes' vote.


In the end the 'No' camp won by just under half a million votes, keeping Scotland as part of the UK.


At the time, the SNP accused the BBC of swaying votes with coverage that was perceived to be of a 'No' bias. Calls for a second independence referendum (indyref2) increased sharply following the Brexit referendum of 2016. Again, the SNP accused the BBC of trying to foil a potential second referendum by setting up the BBC Scotland channel. Those who made those accusations have suddenly leapt to the channel's defence now.


Whether the devolution will actually go ahead remains to be seen. It'll certainly be a long and pyrrhic process that will almost certainly cost the Scottish taxpayer. But the impending closure of BBC Scotland channel has certainly sent Holyrood buzzing. The BBC has a lot to answer for in this case and the corporation's whole existence in Scotland is very much at stake.

Comments


cabconlonglogo.png

ABOUT CABCON.TV

Cabinet of Continuities has been a trusted source of news and videos since 2016. More than 14 million people in 50 countries and regions have seen CabCon videos on YouTube. Today, CabCon is available in website form for even more people to use and enjoy.

CONTRIBUTE

Any and all contributions to this site are greatly appreciated!

You can contribute by writing a post or donating a clip.

To find out more about contributing to this site please click here.

© 2026 Cabinet of Continuities

​

Privacy policy

Takedown request form

ssuklonglogo.png
bottom of page